I could have sworn I was careful not to put that on the hot element...
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/40a0b/40a0b73afba33ee8c9198fbeb09b6058186e0f12" alt="IMG_5623"
At least wool just smolders, rather than bursting into flames. (It's still functional too... just with more, um, "decorative" elements than before.)
Yep, these are different sizes:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/3b8d4/3b8d49bcbcfbcd6e843a60ae733af46e23cfc9ac" alt="IMG_5624"
I knit the previous pair on the recommended size needles, but was having trouble getting gauge. So, for this pair, I did the first (right side) mitten on needles two sizes smaller (I didn't have one size smaller), and it came out nicely. However, as I was finishing up the top, I put the needles in the jar beside my chair as they came out. The "correct" size needles were in the bag... and so, when I went to start the second mitten a day or two later... yep. I used the wrong needles. I noticed the size difference when I went to add the thumbs, but figured I had just not been careful about keeping a tight gauge on the second mitten (having completely forgotten about going down a needle size). It was only later, when I noticed the dpns in the jar, and had a recent recollection of using them, that I remembered what happened.
Yeah, I'm going to rip and reknit the bigger mitten. (It even has some of the ends woven in!)